Pine Barrens Sg Map (Finished)

[Jcamotts]

Hey guys this is my newest Mcsg map please post in the comments what I should add or if it is good enough, thanks. This map was made only by me, it is a 300 radias dome size and it is a hill type terrain with custom pine trees and And a few large mountains. There are a few builds here and their such as a small indian village and an underground mineshaft. There is also a small abonded cottage.

http://imgur.com/HbZaNAI
http://imgur.com/T2i9IEf
http://imgur.com/HZworb8
http://imgur.com/zjtewgL
http://imgur.com/7Mc4wzv
http://imgur.com/6lCRi3B

 

[Jcamotts]

Post in the comments what should be added and what should be taken away.

 

[MeGa_Mushroom]

I love this, look's epic and would love to see it added. But one thing I think you need to add is to make mine shaft system being accessible from multiple parts of the map, Kinda like underground tunnels.

 

[Jcamotts]

I love this, look's epic and would love to see it added. But one thing I think you need to add is to make mine shaft system being accessible from multiple parts of the map, Kinda like underground tunnels.

Thx for the great idea I think I might add this

 

[Frenchipino]

Love this map! I would also love to see it as an MCSG Map! Great job!!

 

[hobo1955]

Too generic and boring

 

[Jcamotts]

Too generic and boring

You mean I should add more builds?

 

[llama5876]

Could you add a download link so that we can be able to look at the map in more detail and give more constructive criticism?

 

[Dusk]

I think the map has a lot of potential. I would like to play this, but looks like you're just relying on mainly just the terrain. Add more builds and traps for better chances!

 

[Sayf]

So, the reason I voted no isn't because I wanted to be rude it was because this map looks too much a like other maps. I mean, spawn looks like Sg1 cave systems like Sg5 / Lost Mine so.. this isn't really original. And, personally I think the community would LOVE to see new original maps. My suggestions here is to wait until 1.6, they're going to add new blocks and carpets. You'll be able to improve your spawn a lot more then and also change the theme because plenty of the current maps already have a forest and mountains around it it's becoming boring .

 

[Torchy // aezlurr]

I agree alot with Nureactor in the way of saying, it's not a bad map. It isn't bad, buts its very overdone, and most 'dense forest' maps are generic, boring, and disliked by the community. Again, it's not bad, it's just past it's time at this point.

 

[Jcamotts]

I agree alot with Nureactor in the way of saying, it's not a bad map. It isn't bad, buts its very overdone, and most 'dense forest' maps are generic, boring, and disliked by the community. Again, it's not bad, it's just past it's time at this point.

So, the reason I voted no isn't because I wanted to be rude it was because this map looks too much a like other maps. I mean, spawn looks like Sg1 cave systems like Sg5 / Lost Mine so.. this isn't really original. And, personally I think the community would LOVE to see new original maps. My suggestions here is to wait until 1.6, they're going to add new blocks and carpets. You'll be able to improve your spawn a lot more then and also change the theme because plenty of the current maps already have a forest and mountains around it it's becoming boring .

I thank you both for the constructive criticism, its what I need xD I am still working on more builds so it will not just be a plain old Forest map.