• Our Minecraft servers are offline but we will keep this forum online for any community communication. Site permissions for posting could change at a later date but will remain online.

My anonymous complaints on MCSG as of 7/25/2013 6:31 AM

ImASecretWriter

Spectator
Joined
Jul 25, 2013
Messages
11
Reaction score
14
Ok, after reading your little 'complaint' here, this is what I pointed out.

You like:
-The revamped lobby
-The quality of some maps
-Some things about MCSG V2 (which you didn't really specify)

You dislike/are disappointed about:
-The quality of newer maps
-Amount of chest loot
-The chat colour
-Inability to place water/lava
-Lightning strikes where people die
-Names of the people who die appearing
-Age of most moderators
-The people who say how much they HATE the revamped lobby.
-Etc.

Notice how your list of dislikes is noticeably longer that the list of things you like, and that most things in the 'dislike' list are complete nitpicks (Chat colour, lightning strikes, etc.)

I also find it odd how you don't want any flaming on this thread, but specifying how much you dislike these changes and the people who dislike the changes you actually like, it only makes me think that you WANT there to be a flame war on here.

By the way, that other thread you linked to, I have a strange feeling that it was also created by you.

I would specify the reasons why I like MCSG, but this isn't a thread ABOUT that is it...? And we can have some disagreements without flaming, there's a difference, between a small disagreement and a flame war. It seems that when someone makes a thread with a disagreement on it everyone assumes it would be a flame war, I'm trying my best to keep it positive here, I'm trying.
 

NorthStar

Career
Joined
Feb 21, 2013
Messages
656
Reaction score
257
I would specify the reasons why I like MCSG, but this isn't a thread ABOUT that is it...? And we can have some disagreements without flaming, there's a difference, between a small disagreement and a flame war. It seems that when someone makes a thread with a disagreement on it everyone assumes it would be a flame war, I'm trying my best to keep it positive here, I'm trying.
True, true, not all arguments turn into flame wars, however it really doesn't help the case if you emphasize on how much you dislike some things by using all caps and/or bold font on certain words.

Oh, and it wouldn't hurt to specify on what you do like about V2, even if that isn't the general topic of the thread. It would make you sound a lot less 'pessimistic' about the whole update.
 

EvermoreHD

Peacekeeper
Joined
Mar 3, 2013
Messages
1,760
Reaction score
1,095
If a staff member is mature, regardless of age, let them be moderator. If they only accepted 18+, there would be a severe lack of moderators...
 

ImASecretWriter

Spectator
Joined
Jul 25, 2013
Messages
11
Reaction score
14
True, true, not all arguments turn into flame wars, however it really doesn't help the case if you emphasize on how much you dislike some things by using all caps and/or bold font on certain words.

The bold/caps really have no meaning, they are just key words. If people need to re-read a certain part, the bold can help direct them instead of skimming the wall of text again. - That I thought was the purpose of it.
 

NorthStar

Career
Joined
Feb 21, 2013
Messages
656
Reaction score
257
The bold/caps really have no meaning, they are just key words. If people need to re-read a certain part, the bold can help direct them instead of skimming the wall of text again. - That I thought was the purpose of it.
It can be used for that purpose, but it depends on how people read it and what context they put it in. For example: you put the caps and bolded words in the context of making the thread more easy to follow, whereas I (and possibly a few others) put it in the context of emphasis. So you could further express your opinion on certain things. I'm going to leave it at that.
 

shoottomaim

Peacekeeper
Joined
Apr 10, 2013
Messages
1,140
Reaction score
765
Hold on I KNOW the limit was raised to 15, so for that reason they shouldn't be demoted or the anything, and exceptions can be made for young people aswell, but is there any ACTIVE moderators, that are over 18? The average server on several video games including minecraft's staff is around 16-30.
:D.
 

Toast

District 13
Joined
Sep 29, 2012
Messages
3,594
Reaction score
4,091
Great post about everything(except for the stuff about staff, because some of it is untrue (most likely due to info that isn't well know publicly)) and I agree on a few things, especially the opness of chests, which are being fixed in the VERY near future.
 

Blamph

District 13
Joined
May 28, 2012
Messages
814
Reaction score
5,107
I read the post, and I wanted to put a bit of my input on the moderator age problem that you stated.

There's various simple reason as to why people who are 18 or older don't apply very often (and trust me, they don't.) When you hit that age, your life changes a lot. I was one of the few 18+ moderators at the time moderating the servers actively last summer, and I had absolutely no problem with it. When you reach 18, responsibilities start pouring onto you, and you eventually find yourself with less time to play Minecraft, let alone dedicate hours a week to actively moderating. The reason why players who are still within that high school age are the perfect fit for a moderating position (if they're mature enough, of course), is that simply put, they have the most time to dedicate. When you're 14 or 15, you don't need a job, which is something that can really damper the amount of time you put into video games.

One last reason, which may not seem very obvious, is that most players who are 18+ generally aim for a much higher position than moderator. It would be false to say that they ALL expect a higher position, but it's true that many wouldn't be happy with holding a simple moderator position for 6 months and no promotion to the Sr. staff side of things. Take a look at the general chunk of Sr. staff, many were the standout younger mods, and the rest are the older group of people. Go even higher to the admin team, and you'll find it's even more the case (with some exception of course.) Not only the active ones, I'm also including past admins and sr. staff.

Anyways, your generality of 16-30 year old's playing this game (the majority) is false. The majority is actually in the 10 - 16 range. It may seem the opposite with the amount of well known YouTuber's being older and all of that, but it's not.
 

ExKing

Platinum
Joined
Oct 15, 2012
Messages
2,550
Reaction score
3,416
I read the post, and I wanted to put a bit of my input on the moderator age problem that you stated.

There's various simple reason as to why people who are 18 or older don't apply very often (and trust me, they don't.) When you hit that age, your life changes a lot. I was one of the few 18+ moderators at the time moderating the servers actively last summer, and I had absolutely no problem with it. When you reach 18, responsibilities start pouring onto you, and you eventually find yourself with less time to play Minecraft, let alone dedicate hours a week to actively moderating. The reason why players who are still within that high school age are the perfect fit for a moderating position (if they're mature enough, of course), is that simply put, they have the most time to dedicate. When you're 14 or 15, you don't need a job, which is something that can really damper the amount of time you put into video games.

One last reason, which may not seem very obvious, is that most players who are 18+ generally aim for a much higher position than moderator. It would be false to say that they ALL expect a higher position, but it's true that many wouldn't be happy with holding a simple moderator position for 6 months and no promotion to the Sr. staff side of things. Take a look at the general chunk of Sr. staff, many were the standout younger mods, and the rest are the older group of people. Go even higher to the admin team, and you'll find it's even more the case (with some exception of course.) Not only the active ones, I'm also including past admins and sr. staff.

Anyways, your generality of 16-30 year old's playing this game (the majority) is false. The majority is actually in the 10 - 16 range. It may seem the opposite with the amount of well known YouTuber's being older and all of that, but it's not.
Gotta love dem blamph posts.
 
Joined
Apr 26, 2012
Messages
1,986
Reaction score
2,055
Good post, I can agree with most of it, even the nitpicks. But for the record I should be on the list of below 15 mods.
 

Gamer101luke

District 13
Joined
Jun 4, 2012
Messages
2,493
Reaction score
1,039
I completely agree with you in the most part except for the fact on team elite, you are obviosly a part of TE and you have your opinion on the maps, but I would say their maps look good, but have no fun game play and are lacking important qualities.
 

Members online

No members online now.

Forum statistics

Threads
242,193
Messages
2,449,610
Members
523,972
Latest member
Atasci