To be completely fair, wins determine level of experience and how dedicated you are, points determine you are either likeable, and get bountied or have skill and earn points legit, and your attitude is basically what gets you far. Everyone should get a chance, even if you guys watch him or her for only a few games, if he is nice and is a good PvP'er then he will prove himself/herself, even if he only has like 50 or so wins, you never know. I will volunteer for an attitude/pvp tester, for the guys who are kind of new or nobody has really seen them. Frankly I'd love that job
That's how I'd set up my clan