• Our Minecraft servers are offline but we will keep this forum online for any community communication. Site permissions for posting could change at a later date but will remain online.

The God Debate

What is your religion?


  • Total voters
    195
Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Aug 3, 2012
Messages
536
Reaction score
709
The idea of God has always been an interesting subject for me. I consider myself agnostic atheist, so while I currently do not believe in a God as in divine creator, I respect any evidence that may be provided in the future to point to the existence of a God. This does not mean I don't believe in an afterlife, which I do. In this post I will give my views and ideas on both sides of the debate.

I explored and done moderate research in Egyptian, Greek, Norse, and Shinto mythologies and lore, and some in Mesopotamian myths. Similarities between all myths and religions originating around the fertile crescent are undeniable. Virgin birth, son of god, healing powers, walking on water, December 25th, and resurrection, are all common themes shared in religions originating around the Mediterranean, and many themes have further roots in nomadic and neolithic man, and their astronomy. My personal favorite adaptation is during the winter solstice on December 21st, the Sun will reach it's lowest point in the sky, and stay in roughly that same latitudinal position for three days, then begin it's cycle across the sky again on December 25th, and as it rises it passes through the Crux constellation, or the southern cross. Rephrasing: The Sun (son) falls for three days, then rises on the 25th on the cross. If that and other religious origins interest you, then I recommend you watch the movie Zeitgeist, A documentary in which the first half discusses religion and the second discusses economic and political conspiracies. The first half also goes into the Christian adoption of pagan beliefs and symbols to make it a more palatable religion for the Europeans to adopt, but I wont be going into further detail on this as I see it is more how religion was used to control rather than the Existence of God.

As for the Universe goes (at least for this plane of existence), I personally believe it is a cycle, much like many things we see around us. The way the cycle works is that, it all begins with a big bang. Then as everything drifts away it loses energy until after trillions of years, it's void of energy. Then, with nothing to fight gravity, it all crashes back in on itself, forming another point consisting of all mass in the universe, and then goes through another big bang, and the cycle continues. Where it all started who knows. Another theory that I like because it's cool but I'm not in personal favor of is that: Black holes take all the mass entered to them and bring it back to start the big bang. Like I say cool, but to me unlikely. All of this can be done without a divine force to push it all into motion, at least as far back as we can go.
Now lets look a little bit forward in time to the creation of life on earth. The Earth, in Theory, was to have been created a billion years before the oldest record-able evidence of ancient bacterial fossils were found. If we support this theory, then natural laws of nature would have a lot of time to spontaneously produce life. Condition such as the hypothesized ancient Earth have been recreated in labs around the world, and the basic components of lfe can naturally come together, an example: the phospholipid bilayer in cells can be created naturally from how the heads and tails interact with water. As for the creation from all the parts together into a living organism, there are many theories and hypothesis', but we use deliberation to bring back the dead all the time, so could it be possible that lightning could do the same on an ancient pre-cell? In my opinion if life was created through a divine force, then we'd see fossil record much closer to the beginning of Earth, than what we see now, but all is speculation; as evidence could have eroded away, ancient cell might not have been able to leave fossil record (whether due to size or geography) or that earth wasn't in the slightest bit hospitable until we see a fossil record begin to appear (which I find unlikely considering the conditions archaea bacteria thrive in today).
All this is place, scientifically can see a Universe possible without the help or need of a divine creator.

Now onto the metaphysical side of things.
Something I've often heard (even read on the forums) is that without God, life is meaningless and anything we do or don't do will end in oblivion, that is to say nothing, and all will be without point when the universe collapses in on itself. This will be the same way God or not. Any medical break through or scientific discovery made in this existence probably won't matter in the next (Sorry if I'm being depressing here). I don't think humanity will even make it to the end of the universe (if we keep going as we are now, not even to the next millennium). Humanity has gone down this path itself, and we have no one else to blame. But so be it. Evolution is a wonderful thing. It keeps us alive but the most miraculous thing it has done was made organisms focused on oneself's sole survival into a species focused on the betterment of the group in the individual. That is why we have scientists and doctors working to keep us alive and healthy, and that is why we award and praise them so much. We as a species care for each other. And just because it will end, as all things will, every game, every anime, every life, we will keep working and going as long as we can. It's just in our nature. A God or no God won't change whats happening and what's to come.

The afterlife and other planes of existence is often brought up with God, and the two seem to coexist together. I don't feel as an afterlife requires the existence of God. A hypothesis brought up by my Biology teacher is one that got me thinking.
First, you are a sperm and egg, separate. This could be the first plane of life, then you come together and create a cell and this is the next plane of existence. Then your a fetus. All you know is the womb. Yes there is an outside that you have some interaction with, but you don't know what's there all you know is your mom's womb in this third plane of existence. Then you enter the fourth when you are born. You can interact further with what was outside the womb, yet your mind is still very closed off. Then you enter the fifth, most of the time in toddler years. This is when memories start coming, you become self aware, and you can interact with the world. This from memories and interactions is where I believe the soul takes existence. Perhaps we, here in this hypothetical fifth existence, are just waiting in another gestation period are just waiting to go into the next stage of existence and interaction and the birth into this existence, is our death; where much like we cast aside the sperm cell coat when leaving the first existence, we cast aside our bodies and a soul of memories transcends to the next.This is just an idea, and there are many others out there, it just means to me that God doesn't have to be there for an afterlife.

Now as for God existing, it is quite possible as well. Perhaps not scientifically, as I don't think sufficient evidence will ever come up for the existence of a divine creator as science deals with observable physical phenomenon and God has to deal with meta-physics.

The best argument for the existence of God which may apply to some (but not me personally) is that rather that the starting force it is a guiding hand for how things are to be. I see this being far more possoble than a divine creator, but to me (personal opinion completely) to be called God you must have created it and not simply be guiding the machine.

I personally believe that one should believe in what makes them happy. I used to be hardcore atheist, and shamefully admit bashed on my friends sometime. But it was no life for me. I found the idea of Oblivion after death depressing, yet God never made sense to me. The idea of another existence or afterlife is much more comforting, but I don't believe a divine creator is waiting there. (going a little crazy here but lets roll with it). To me we I believe we all have a soul that comes from the interactions we make with the world. Everything, has some sort of soul or stimulant to cause soul growth. The development begins at birth, when you truly come into your own separate being and then grows into your own individual soul. When you die I believe this becomes your afterlife; your soul escapes into itself, and you exist in detail everything you've interacted with or caused you experience. You choose your afterlife by what you experience now, this goes from imagination, to family, to research you've done. Every part that combines into your soul exists here including your own soul and you can spend your afterlife doing what makes you happy. It's a weird idea I'm still developing. I'm just trying to to build a belief that makes me happy, but won't significantly interfere with the behavior of the universe.

Anyway if I made it this far thanks for reading. I'm sorry, I tried my best not to offend anyone, but if I did I sincerely apologize. The purpose was to give my ideas on this topic and I feel satisfied with what i wrote (though I'll probably think of another paragraph later xD) feel free to reply with your own views on ideas I brought up
 

Ssosme

Survivor
Joined
Sep 19, 2014
Messages
197
Reaction score
104
I am a Christian and was raised in a christian family. I go to church and do Sunday school about every weekend. I am really devoted to my faith. I am not one of those "religious" freaks but I do stand for what I believe in.

I believe God exists because spiritually:
This might not show evidence of his existence but it shows how he saved me personally in my faith. He saved me from my heart of stone, too a heart of flesh. It changed my life, revealing his glory through his word. This is mostly sounding like emotional feeling, but it is truly life changing for me.

I believe God exists because of evidence:
A lot of documents show a existence of a God. But we cannot PROVE there is one. But the bible is basically a big documentary explaining the miracles God and Jesus preformed. Also God has showed his glory since the beginning of the universe. He created man and woman in the beginning. God created the universe so he could demonstrate his power to the earth and have people glorify his name.

Other people say that the universe was created by the "BIG BANG" - People ask for proof of a God, I always ask for proof of the Big Ban Theory. The big bang theory suggests that the universe was formed from nothing... Basically saying it just "randomly" happened. Which makes no sense. How can something just come from nothing? There is so much detail for the human race to live on a planet and how were humans created in the exact design so they can live and communicate.

Where with Christianity--- there is a supreme creator- God. Christianity stats that there is a God and he created the world and everything in it perfectly. What I mean by perfectly- is that he created it where everything is in perfect detail. The plants grow because there is sun and the water. Humans eat and it digests. Our bodies are made with a brain, heart, etc. Its so much detail. Its hard to say that it was "random."

Well I have to say, a lot of people I have noticed have some facts and stuff guys pointed out.

I noticed on the first page of this thread someone said "God never said anything bad about being gay."--- Yes he did say being homosexual. If you take a look at Leviticus 18:22 he says lying with a man as you would with a woman is an abomination to the lord. I'm stating this because you said your friends said to you that God is fine with gays. Which I found in the bible stats that he absolutely hates it.

Also people stat "The earth has been around for millions of years." I would like to say where you got this from. If you base it off because scientists say it. They have no authority over what has been created. The earth has only been documented for over 6000 years. We have books, writings, scripts stating this fact. Saying that the earth has been around for millions of years makes no sense and there is no documents on it.
 

ALL1DO1SW1N

District 13
Joined
Sep 22, 2012
Messages
1,688
Reaction score
2,217
I don't really believe in something, to be honest I am not sure what to believe in. I am not Atheist, Christian, Buddhist, Catholic, Lutheran, etc. But I have a question for others, please don't start flame but I would like to hear other people's opinions/ideas. This has pondered my mind for many years and I have never actually got a serious response. Who created god? How does he exist without nothing to create him? Again I'm not very religious and I would like to learn other people's beliefs on this question.
 

OrangesAndLemons95

Experienced
Joined
Nov 8, 2014
Messages
110
Reaction score
159
“Is God willing to prevent evil, but not able? Then he is not omnipotent.
Is he able, but not willing? Then he is malevolent.
Is he both able and willing? Then whence cometh evil?
Is he neither able nor willing? Then why call him God?”


Read it and weap.
 

Ssosme

Survivor
Joined
Sep 19, 2014
Messages
197
Reaction score
104
I don't really believe in something, to be honest I am not sure what to believe in. I am not Atheist, Christian, Buddhist, Catholic, Lutheran, etc. But I have a question for others, please don't start flame but I would like to hear other people's opinions/ideas. This has pondered my mind for many years and I have never actually got a serious response. Who created god? How does he exist without nothing to create him? Again I'm not very religious and I would like to learn other people's beliefs on this question.
This is actually a good question. I mean his name is "God" nothing created him. He has existed forever. There was never a time he wasn't in existence. Our human brains just aren't built to know that or grasp that he has been forever. And plus we can't know everything. If we knew these kind of things we would know everything and eventually that would place humans as God. There are reasons why we are limited knowledge.
 

smashmaster

Platinum
Joined
Nov 1, 2012
Messages
4,924
Reaction score
5,767
I am a Christian, not the best at being one but I do believe in God... Its all ive got left
 

RichyCrafter

Platinum
Joined
Sep 18, 2013
Messages
119
Reaction score
204
I highly suggest you watch what all of you say because religion can easily cause flame wars, personally I am an agnostic atheist (my dad doesn't know this because he is very much catholic) if I were to see evidence of "God" I would probably switch until then nope.
 

Scott

District 13
Joined
Mar 31, 2014
Messages
2,359
Reaction score
2,763
I am a Christian. Personally, that is what keeps me going every day is the belief in a wonderful God. Just reading the bible was enough for me.
 
Joined
Jun 27, 2012
Messages
583
Reaction score
859
I noticed on the first page of this thread someone said "God never said anything bad about being gay."--- Yes he did say being homosexual. If you take a look at Leviticus 18:22 he says lying with a man as you would with a woman is an abomination to the lord. I'm stating this because you said your friends said to you that God is fine with gays. Which I found in the bible stats that he absolutely hates it.
I think you are talking about me, please read my updated post on the first page. I worded things wrong. Please respond when you see it.
 

CruelDefiance

Career
Joined
Jun 17, 2013
Messages
488
Reaction score
986
We are all God, the universal consciousness, with infinite awareness. The universe is heaven, a place for our eternal spirit to manifest and exist in order to express love. Our minds are the ultimate power, we can all communicate with eachother with telepathy, we can feel eachothers thoughts and project thoughts to others. We can project our astral forms and go anywhere and see everything in the universe just within our minds. There are higher dimensions of existence past the physical realms, this is where we originate and where we return when our bodies die. Love everything and everyone because it is you, for you. Practice meditation every day and relax your body and quiet your mind, that is how you can open yourself to recieve the information that the spiritual guardians and higher beings are sending us all the time.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Members online

No members online now.

Forum statistics

Threads
242,193
Messages
2,449,633
Members
523,972
Latest member
Atasci