Refute of #1: The lava mountain had two, albeit quite risky, yet somewhat less-traveled extremely well-tiered routes (both the parkour through the top as well as the lava-sheet cave thing in the side. Tomahawk's Breeze Island route on Freeze gets two new tier IIs (the one in the tree on one side of the rickety bridge and the other on the second floor of the diving board house). Those are merely two other chest routes that were even more easily accessible than the creeper eye. Plus, to be honest, the creeper eye was one of the most dangerous routes on the map - even more so, to my mind, than both lava ones.
Refute of #2: So? There are little to no chests in the water on Breeze Island and Breeze V2, but that just means the chests are all found near landmarks. This is the case on most of the classic SG maps. You have to go looking for chests. It'd be too easy to just find chests lying out in the open for all to see (e.g.: Winds of Change).
Refute of #3: Breeze Island's water PVP is even more annoying than Freeze, and Demon's Breeze is annoying because, well, duh. Ice PVP is hilarious, ends a hell of a lot more quickly than water chases (not as much time to eat or utilize a fishing rod), and is a good way to practice your fishing rod combos with its "jousting" style of play.
