Map Review of Every 24-Player MCSG Map

[Mamiamato24]

It just isn't as popular on US. My apologies.

Like you said, we all have our opinions. I just offered mine as a way to possibly help with some decisions.

The thing is, people have different opinions, so it would be very difficult to point out maps that a majority of people would want gone. Some people appreciate looks over gameplay, some a balance, and some vice versa. The critique is in the eye of the beholder.

 

[SuperxAndrew]

I agree with everything except Fortress Pyke, I believe it is played often enough to stay, classic, and my favourite map.
Also, you forgot the map Enchanted Forest.

Thanks for the feedback.

 

[Mamiamato24]

You've inspired me to make this thread :3
http://www.minecraftsurvivalgames.com/threads/maps-youd-like-to-see-gone.111002/

 

[darkai202]

They just aren't as popular on US. My apologies. My opinions about them still stand though.

Oh no, it's fine haha, you acknowledged it as a really good map, which it is... However, it is actually kind of popular, so I personally think it should stay.

 

[SuperxAndrew]

Oh no, it's fine haha, you acknowledged it as a really good map, which it is... However, it is actually kind of popular, so I personally think it should stay.

I edited the thread. Take a look. xD

 

[1qw3er5t6y]

Lobby games is now a good map because the actual lobby is cut off. Don't even get me started on hub games and wasteland those two maps are a joke. Like an actual joke, not very funny though

 

[darkai202]

I edited the thread. Take a look. xD

Niceee, nicee.

 

[Tryhard_Batman]

Darn that was a good read! Great review and eye-opening points.

 

[SuperxAndrew]

Lobby games is now a good map because the actual lobby is cut off. Don't even get me started on hub games and wasteland those two maps are a joke. Like an actual joke, not very funny though

I just am not a fan of Lobby Games. I understand your points though.

Darn that was a good read! Great review and eye-opening points.

Glad you liked the post.

 

[Cinci | Kame]

I agree with all but
Demons Breeze,
Yes it is a remake but it is different enough to be interesting, plus, you have to be more conservative when running from or to people due to how sketchy is
Fortune Island,
It makes long games but it is really nice for pvp (at least for me)
Fallen Empire,
needs to be gone not only because of size and no votes, the tiering is terrible, I don't know if they fixed this but you can get like 7 tier 2's right off corn if you know where to go. and they are within 100 block radius.
Moonbase 9,
The darkness and just wide open feel of the map adds a nice pvp zone, yes the terraforming might be off but it is still good.
Note,
I'm sorry Bayani but I think Breeze 2 V2 needs to go, it is too close to the original and it really isn't TOO different. Its got the main island, other islands, ships, lots of water, Its just got a different look and lily pads everywhere.

 

[SuperxAndrew]

I agree with all but
Demons Breeze,
Yes it is a remake but it is different enough to be interesting, plus, you have to be more conservative when running from or to people due to how sketchy is
Fortune Island,
It makes long games but it is really nice for pvp (at least for me)
Fallen Empire,
needs to be gone not only because of size and no votes, the tiering is terrible, I don't know if they fixed this but you can get like 7 tier 2's right off corn if you know where to go. and they are within 100 block radius.
Moonbase 9,
The darkness and just wide open feel of the map adds a nice pvp zone, yes the terraforming might be off but it is still good.
Note,
I'm sorry Bayani but I think Breeze 2 V2 needs to go, it is too close to the original and it really isn't TOO different. Its got the main island, other islands, ships, lots of water, Its just got a different look and lily pads everywhere.

Thanks for the opinions.

 

[Braden]

One of the most underplayed but best tiering and builds: Remnant (I believe it is by Fyre UK). Almost every chest is a tier 2 and the build quality is amazing.