Thinking Thread | Rating the MCSG maps

[leMaCderp]

90000, 9000, 9000, 90000000, 9000, 90000000, 9000, 900000, 900000, 9000, 90000, 9000, 9000, 90000, 9000, 9000, 9000, 9000, 9000, 9001

 

[Sup3rT0nyRocks]

Survival Games 1- 10/10 Love this personally as a Hunger Games Fanatic
Survival Games 2- 7/10 Amazing aesthetics
Survival Games 3- 6.5/10 Awesome secnery and great building
Survival Games 4- 5.5/10 Too overplayed
Survival Games 5- 10/10 Love this personally
Breeze Island- 6.5/10 Too much water fights
Insanity Cause- 4/10 Lack of chests and odd structures and too much SHRUBBERY
Teweran SG 1- 9/10
Teweran SG 2- 9/10
Kharmunrah- 4/10
Fortress Pyke- 6/10
Survival Kingdom- 7/10
SG Ancient Japan- 4/10
Moonlight Lake- 5/10
Asia Games- 2/10 Super Random, not sorted and alot of mistakes, Dont know how it was accepted
Solar Frost- 7/10

Removed:
MCSG Ruins- Never played
Hungry Hills- 10/10 Love this Personally dont know why it was removed, CHAD, GET ON TO THIS!
Skylands Survival- 9/10
Overgrown Arena- Never played
Yellowstone- 1.5/10

 

[ShaunDepro]

Survival Games 1- 7
Survival Games 2- 10
Survival Games 3- 9
Survival Games 4- 4
Survival Games 5- 7
Breeze Island- 8
Insanity Cause- 6
Teweran SG 1- 8
Teweran SG 2- 9
Kharmunrah- 6
Fortress Pyke- 5
Survival Kingdom- 5
Ancient Japan- 3
Moonlight Lake- 4
Asia Games- 4
Solar Frost- 5

Removed:
MCSG Ruins- 1
Hungry Hills- 4
Skylands Survival- 3
Overgrown Arena- 6
Yellowstone- 4

 

[static_nightmare]

Survival Games 1- 7/10- Enjoyable and a classic, but compared to what else there is, it can't be my favourite
Survival Games 2- 10/10- Love it, want to play more and more of it. 'Nuff said.
Survival Games 3- 9/10- Highly underrated, may be quite large, but a very enjoyable map
Survival Games 4- 8/10- Nicely made and fun to play on, hate how its quite overplayed
Survival Games 5- 9/10- Doesn't get played enough. Fun to play on, just needs a little more than awesome builds
Breeze Island- 4/10- Has a large list of problems I should probably fix. Maybe it's had its time, despite continued popularity by the noobs. Should be a 'once in a while map' rather than 'every third game'
Insanity Cause- 7/10- Better than breeze. Tight environments are an issue. Wish to see more people on the canopy, but doesn't turn out that way usually. I just love my oil rig
Teweran SG 1- 10/10- Team Teweran just do amazing things
Teweran SG 2- 10/10- As above
Kharmunrah- 5/10- Effort, but ridiculous terraforming, and awkward builds.
Fortress Pyke- 7/10- Love the structures, wish there weren't world-painter trees and just vanilla ones.
Survival Kingdom- 8/10 Nice map to play on, just very obvious chest placement and annoying corn.
Ancient Japan- 6/10 Similar to SK in a lot of bad ways. Too much wood, and far too neat.
Moonlight Lake- 5/10 Too small, not enough chests. Corn is unfair.
Asia Games- 5/10 Random asian-looking structures on seemingly vanilla terrain. Could be much more authentic.
Solar Frost- 6/10 Too small. Nice details, but just weird overall.

Removed:
MCSG Ruins- 3/10- Don't even get me started on that map... Most unthought out corn ever, vanilla map, structures copied from SG4 and vanilla MC.
Hungry Hills- 5/10 Just too big. World Painter trees are ugly too.
Skylands Survival- No opinion. Only ever played it once, and got killed too quickly to get an opinion.
Overgrown Arena- 7/10 Size is an issue, but a fairly decent job nevertheless.
Yellowstone-4/10 Ugly and unrealistic. Don't know why people like it so so much

 

[Hystericallify]

Too much typing on a phone, so I'll simply say: G33ke post here

 

[Eskild]

Survival Games 1- 5
Survival Games 2- 7
Survival Games 3- 8
Survival Games 4- 8
Survival Games 5- 6
Breeze Island- 3
Insanity Cause- 2
Teweran SG 1- 7
Teweran SG 2- 10
Kharmunrah- 8
Fortress Pyke- 2
Survival Kingdom- 4
Ancient Japan- 4
Moonlight Lake- 2
Asia Games- [Never Played In fact...]
Solar Frost- 10

Removed:
MCSG Ruins- 2
Hungry Hills- 3
Skylands Survival- 6
Overgrown Arena- 3
Yellowstone- 7

-WILL ADD COMMENTS LATER! I'm on mobile and at school, so I don't want to do comments at

 

[iMightTroll]

Survival Games 1- 5
Survival Games 2- Over 9000000000
Survival Games 3- 8
Survival Games 4- 3
Survival Games 5- 5
Breeze Island- 0
Insanity Cause- 0
Teweran SG 1- 900000000000000000000000000000
Teweran SG 2- 7
Kharmunrah- 7 (to big)
Fortress Pyke- 8
Survival Kingdom- 1000000000
Ancient Japan- 1
Moonlight Lake- 9
Asia Games- 0
Solar Frost- over 900000000

Removed:
MCSG Ruins- 4
Hungry Hills- 6
Skylands Survival- 5
Overgrown Arena- 1000000000
Yellowstone- 0

 

[Drybear1998]

Survival Games 1- 3/10 (atm) The pirate ship is WAY too op. If you don't manage to win the race of the pirate ship you have basicly lost if you're not a really good PVPer. Before the MCSGv2 update i would have rated it 6/10 because i love the survival feeling and i don't find it that hard to find players.
Survival Games 2- 3/10 I joined MCSG when breeze island just got added, SG2 was not popular back then so i didn't manage to learn any chest route or anything. I have one now but i still feel like it's the first time i play that map when i visit a few areas that i usually never go to.
Survival Games 3- 5/10 I have a good chestroute and i kinda like how the map looks, it's waaaaaay too hard to find players though.
Survival Games 4- 7/10 Before MCSGv2 i used to be one of those people that goes like "Vote for SG4 and i'll rip your head off!" But i kinda like it now, i don't know what happened...
Survival Games 5- 9/10 Jeeesus i love this map! the builds, the exeperience, the lack of tier 2s (there is a few now though), i also don't find it hard to find players at all. But there's one thing, the corn. It's different which i kinda like, but down in these tunnels i get punched to death like 30% of the time, not fun at all...
Breeze Island- 7/10 I like it because it's small and the games are short and intence it is way too overplayed though
Insanity Cause- ?/10 I've only played it once and i died straight away... i cannot rate it.
Teweran SG 1- 8/10 I really like this map! it's very detailed and has a balanced amount of chests, i love the survival experience on this map too.
Teweran SG 2- 7/10 One of the most detailed map that ive ever played, it is a bit too big though imo.
Kharmunrah- 2/10 Nah, just, just, naaaah
Fortress Pyke- 8/10 Was my favorite map a while ago, they nerfed my route though so it's not as awesome enymore :/
Survival Kingdom- 6/10 very well built map, but the OP goldapples are annoying, i also think it's too big.
Ancient Japan- 3/10 I'm lagging badly on this map.. i don't really like it at all either..
Moonlight Lake- 4/10 If there's a stone sword at corn it't just a disaster. I haven't played it much either byt so far i don't like it.
Asia Games- ?/10 never played
Solar Frost- 10/10 ERMHAGWWEEEERDD, I frickin LOVE this map, i don't know what to say, it's just awesome!!

Removed:
MCSG Ruins- ?/10 never played
Hungry Hills- 5/10 i had a BEATS chestroute until it got nerfed and later the map got removed. It was so huge that i only had timed deathmatches on it though
Skylands Survival- 4/10 meh... too big and almost no structures.
Overgrown Arena- ?/10 Never played
Yellowstone- 1/10 never again, i'm glad it got removed...

 

[Captain Dak]

Survival Games 1- 5
Survival Games 2- Over 9000000000
Survival Games 3- 8
Survival Games 4- 3
Survival Games 5- 5
Breeze Island- 0
Insanity Cause- 0
Teweran SG 1- 900000000000000000000000000000
Teweran SG 2- 7
Kharmunrah- 7 (to big)
Fortress Pyke- 8
Survival Kingdom- 1000000000
Ancient Japan- 1
Moonlight Lake- 9
Asia Games- 0
Solar Frost- over 900000000

Removed:
MCSG Ruins- 4
Hungry Hills- 6
Skylands Survival- 5
Overgrown Arena- 1000000000
Yellowstone- 0

lol, all ratings of over 9000 will count as 10's I guess

 

[darkai202]

Survival Games 1- 4/10 - Terribly built, just a forest with alot of water really.
Survival Games 2- 6/10 - Not bad, just to big so it's hard to find people, good gameplay.
Survival Games 3- 5/10 - Meh, big, decent builds. Don't love it.
Survival Games 4- 8/10 - Alright builds, not to special, but amazing gameplay.
Survival Games 5- 7/10 - Not good gameplay, but I just love the map.
Breeze Island- 6/10 - Eeew water
Insanity Cause- 9/10 - I just love this map! Really good gameplay in my opinion.
Teweran SG 1- 8/10 - AMAZING JEKSJDJAJSIXJEB
Teweran SG 2- 6/10 - Less amazing... Still good. c:
Kharmunrah- 2/10 - eeeeew terrible builds terrible everything
Fortress Pyke- 8/10 - A smaller SG1 with a few cooler things, I like it. :3
Survival Kingdom 4/10 - Good gameplay, but takes waaaaay to long. And those traps..
Ancient Japan- 9/10 - Amazing gameplay, great builds. And it lags less than most other maps for me.
Moonlight Lake- 6 1/2/10 Terribly built map, with good gameplay and small. I like it for that.
Asia Games- 1/10 - Eeeeeew burn it
Solar Frost 10/10 - SKKAJDKAJDJJD AMAZING GAME PLAY SMALL FAST SKANDJSJA AMAZING

Removed Maps
MCSG Ruins- 1/10
Hungry Hills- 2/10
Skylands Survival- 3/10
Overgrown Arena- 1/10
Yellowstone- 0.1/10

These were removed for a reason, no comment.

 

[darkai202]

Blamph

I spent alot of time on this joke.

Why did the blamph cross the road?

To get away from Breeze Island

I'm a natural comedian right? :3

 

[Jon | Lqzer]

This is a great idea! Maybe they'll add back in Hungry Hills if enough people like it.
Survival Games 1- 8/10- I used to hate this map, until I stumbled upon an amazing chest route by chance. Also, this map usually lasts till the second refill. I am almost always the only one there!
Survival Games 2- 4/10- Meh. You have to have a good route for this one because there are only so many tier 2's.
Survival Games 3- 6/10- SG3 is a large map and it comes with pros and cons. I usually have no problem finding chests, but none of them are very good.
Survival Games 4- 3/10- This map is overplayed and it is a bloodbath. People race each other to the "awesome" chest routes where they die. I don't see why baccas like this map because they never win. It's too small...
Survival Games 5- 6/10- I'm indifferent on this one. I used to love it. Now it's meh. Hardly any tier 2 chests makes for a poor experience. It's fun, though.
Breeze Island- 7/10- I have to admit: Breeze is actually growing on me! My chest route is now boss and I can usually make it to deathmatch every time. In this map, I can also be very lucky (stealing people's drops after fights).
Insanity Cause- 8/10- I love Insanity Cause. It's short and sweet. Often times the deathmatch isn't overmatched. Usually everyone has basic armor and weapons, which is ok because there are no AMAZING chest routes. I, though, have a GREAT chest route.
Teweran SG 1-
Teweran SG 2- 3/10- I often starve on this map. 'Nuff said.
Kharmunrah- 2/10- This map is too sandy with not enough anything. Moving on.
Fortress Pyke- 6/10- The chest locations on here are like the ones on Sg4, but there are more of them. There is a better chance to win.
Survival Kingdom- 10/10. The only complaint I have is that it also is starting to get overplayed. MY CHEST ROUTE IS BOSS. Every single time- my route is secret. I ALWAYS get a diamond sword- unless I get killed before I can craft it. Almost every time- Full iron armor. The only thing that makes this 9 tier 2 chest route better (I don't even need corn) is my secret weapon that wins me every game in deathmatch.
Ancient Japan- 8/10. I stumbled apon a great chest route and usually have a diamond sword within the first 3 minutes (unless I get killed at the crafting table -_-).
Moonlight Lake- 8/10- TONS of tier 2 chests are available, which makes this map fun (especially if you have shears)!
Asia Games- 6/10- My route is amazing, but 9 out of 10 times I fall 1000 feet to my death on the route.
Solar Frost- 7/10- This map frustrates me because it is a bloodbath, and having the best gear doesn't guarantee a win. You can kill a diamond sword holder with a stone sword if they are injured from a recent battle.

Removed:
MCSG Ruins- ?- Never played.
Hungry Hills- 1000000000000000000000000000000000/10- I LOVE HUNGRY HILLS! BRING IT BACK!
Skylands Survival- 2/10- Meh.
Overgrown Arena- ?- Never played.
Yellowstone- 3/10- Meh.