Moonlight Lake - Why Deleting It ?

[GuyK]

Seems you dont take constructive criticism well?
Thats bad, you are gonna be stuck in your own ego if you are like that, that answer wasnt necesary.

Since I havent played the map much I cant give much of an opinion but I will say this... first of all, I am neutral about the map, I dont like it but I dont dislike it either... then I must say that from even your signature it is actually true that your map cant be compared with other great maps theres around, I mean, the map you show there pretty much shows that the map is mostly small buildings here and there, water and trees.... not much at all.
Now, what Im going for is to say that, even if I dont think it shouldnt be deleted since it seems many people like it, you cannot make this complaint, you already got the chance to have it on the servers, not everybody gets that... if I were you Id just move on and take what people have told me as constructive criticism and build a new map or improve the current one.


Yet again... from your rude answer to Matt's point of view Im sure youll just ignore this but I want to point out that what Ive said is just constructive criticism, I dont intend to hurt you in any way... so if I did, I apologize.

lol It wasn't rude ^^
You dont even know what mods say to me lol .
I do take constructive criticism but not spam.

Seems you dont take constructive criticism well?
Thats bad, you are gonna be stuck in your own ego if you are like that, that answer wasnt necesary.

Since I havent played the map much I cant give much of an opinion but I will say this... first of all, I am neutral about the map, I dont like it but I dont dislike it either... then I must say that from even your signature it is actually true that your map cant be compared with other great maps theres around, I mean, the map you show there pretty much shows that the map is mostly small buildings here and there, water and trees.... not much at all.
Now, what Im going for is to say that, even if I dont think it shouldnt be deleted since it seems many people like it, you cannot make this complaint, you already got the chance to have it on the servers, not everybody gets that... if I were you Id just move on and take what people have told me as constructive criticism and build a new map or improve the current one.


Yet again... from your rude answer to Matt's point of view Im sure youll just ignore this but I want to point out that what Ive said is just constructive criticism, I dont intend to hurt you in any way... so if I did, I apologize.

Btw , New map coming soon .
It has a lot of terreformings ^^
"Fantasy Dream"

 

[Damoisawesome]

I say get pirate bay on the servers

 

[Vaangel]

My view on this.
MCSG shouldn't have added these 'bad' or poorly made maps in the first place. People may disagree but asking the community what maps should be added or removed is a TERRIBLE , TERRIBLE idea , because they will just keep the maps that they win on regularly or the ones they have a good chest route on. I think MCSG should have a group of pro builders taken from different build teams to judge the maps and they can vote amongst themselves which ones to scrap and which ones to keep. Personally I think moonlight and the new breeze islands should be removed. But anyway, MCSG needs to raise their bar and try get a new epic build team to help out. There are plenty out there and just because they aren't team vareide doesn't make them any worse. Fyreuk or mithrintia for example I'm sure wouldn't mind helping out.

Exactly what I am saying, which no one seems to understand.

MCSG is getting better. They are aiming towards a bigger community and more professional/good looking servers. To reach this goal, Chad has decided to start by removing bad maps, replacing them with good looking maps (maps that were looking just like TV's maps- beautiful) and so on. When I joined the MCSG community back in August, there were only good looking maps- SG1, SG2, SG3 and Breeze Island. These maps are what I would consider as QUALITY maps. They made me think "Wow! These servers must be amazing, just look at the maps I can play!". Those days are gone. Nowadays, there are a bunch of maps. Most of them are community maps. Most of them are NOT quality maps. Moonlight Lake is one of those. MCSG is working on fixing everything back to the excellent way it was- by removing bad stuff, replacing it with great stuff.

 

[usmoothie]

I say get pirate bay on the servers

pirate bay sux balls

 

[Angryjukebox]

pirate bay sux balls

Please don't say rude things like that which may cause a flame war, it is not needed.

 

[Vaangel]

pirate bay sux balls

So does your grammar.

 

[inconceivable81]

#KeepMoonlightLakeOnMCSGOrRIP!

 

[BlitzCometITU]

The choices MCSG makes are so bad. For real, Moonlight Lake is played A LOT, and thats why it should stay. My logic here? I play Breeze island almost as much as I do Moonlight lake, so in this case, LETS REMOVE BREEZE TOO?! But hey, that will never happen because it has "terraforming". There are so many maps that community hates, and yet they decide to remove a enjoyed map. Imo, we should remove: Asia Games, Fortress Pyke, Karmunrah or whatever, and Valleyside (until its fixed). I love ValleySide, but the no drop bug is game changing, and it isn't fun to play if you kill a guy in full iron and get none of it...

 

[hobo1955]

The choices MCSG makes are so bad. For real, Moonlight Lake is played A LOT, and thats why it should stay. My logic here? I play Breeze island almost as much as I do Moonlight lake, so in this case, LETS REMOVE BREEZE TOO?! But hey, that will never happen because it has "terraforming". There are so many maps that community hates, and yet they decide to remove a enjoyed map. Imo, we should remove: Asia Games, Fortress Pyke, Karmunrah or whatever, and Valleyside (until its fixed). I love ValleySide, but the no drop bug is game changing, and it isn't fun to play if you kill a guy in full iron and get none of it...

They are removing it as the quality of the build does not meet MCSG standards. And yes they are removing demon's breeze.

 

[BlitzCometITU]

They are removing it as the quality of the build does not meet MCSG standards. And yes they are removing demon's breeze.

Are you kidding me... Demon's was the most liked out of the three.

 

[hobo1955]

I

Are you kidding me... Demon's was the most liked out of the three.

it's not about the community enjoying the maps , it's about the standards that need to be set for Survival Games' biggest network of servers. Personally I think they are making the right call.

 

[Zoeticly]

I
it's not about the community enjoying the maps , it's about the standards that need to be set for Survival Games' biggest network of servers. Personally I think they are making the right call.

standards? so a remake of a map already created is okay with mcsg?